I recently completed a ranking analysis of 195 law school home pages, entitled the "Top 10 Law School Home Pages of 2009" The entire report is on SSRN and will be posted elsewhere later. This report looks at fourteen separate design elements, which were evaluated in November/December 2009. Elements were given weighted values to equal 100 points for a perfect score. Nobody got 100 points, but the survey reveals some interesting details about the state of law school home pages.
Here are some interesting numbers, showing how many schools out of 195 some of the elements surveyed:
- Use at least one microformat element: 4
- Define at least one Dublin Core element: 4
- Use embedded media (audio or video) playable directly from the page: 11
- Have a favicon defined: 144
- Display one or more social network badges/links: 47
- Include a picture of a smiling face: 170
The printed results will be in the Green Bag Almanac and Reader 2010, which is sent to most Green Bag subscribers. The version on SSRN is identical to the version to appear in print. This project may be repeated again next year. If so, it will be interesting to see how much things change this year. Suggestions for improvements are welcome, and criticism and complaints are okay too.
Read on for a list of the point values as well as a full abstract for the report.
Element Name and Points Assigned:
- Address 10
- Search Box 10
- Cascading Stylesheet (CSS)* 10
- News Headlines 6
- News Headlines with Images 7
- Embedded Media 5
- Favicon 7
- Smiles 5
- Social Network Link 6
- Content Carousel 6
- RSS Meta Information 8
- Microformats 6
- Dublin Core 4
- Hierarchal Organization* 10
* partial points possible for these elements
Perfect Score 100
Abstract:
The website home page represents the virtual front door for any law school. It’s the place many prospective students start in the application process. Enrolled students, law school faculty and other employees often start with the home page to find classes, curricula and compensation plans. Home page content changes constantly. Deciding which home pages are good is often very subjective. Creating a ranking system for “good taste” is perhaps impossible.The ranking report "Top 10 Law School Home Pages of 2009" includes a tabulation of fourteen objective design criteria to analyze and rank 195 law school home pages. The intent was to count only objective criteria to attempt to find the best sites. All law school home pages were ranked based on a weighted analysis of these criteria. Pictures of the ten best sites are included in the report, followed by a full tabulation of all schools evaluated for the report. The goal was to include elements that make websites easier to use for sighted as well as visually-impaired users. Most elements require no special design skills, sophisticated technology or significant expenses.

